Blog

How much email is too much during the holidays?

holiday-email-emma-resource-tile

If you’re mapping your December email sends now, you’re already ahead of most teams. The harder call is deciding just how many emails to send. And while sending more frequently might feel like a smart way to cut through a crowded inbox, it risks two things at once: subscribers who stop opening, and mailbox providers that notice a sudden jump in your volume. 

Here’s how to find an email send cadence that won’t risk creating uninterested subscribers or alarming mailbox providers.

Start out slow, and let your analytics set the pace

Pick a modest holiday frequency, maybe once or twice a week, and watch what happens to your email analytics after each send. If engagement holds across opens and clicks, you probably have room to add another email to the sequence. If your numbers start to dip, pull back and take a look at what the issue might be.

Your subscribers are getting more email from everyone in December, not just your organization, so your open and click rates will be a bit unpredictable no matter what you do. Compare each send against your own seasonal baseline, not against previous months, or you’ll read a normal December dip as a frequency problem and cut sends you don’t need to.

Gradually ramp up your volume

Frequency is how often you send, while volume is how many people you send to, and mailbox providers pay careful attention to both.

If you normally send to a smaller group of your contact list and the holidays have you mailing all of it, that’s a change in pattern as much as a change in schedule, and a sudden change like that might make mailbox providers cautious. Ramping up gradually over a few weeks protects the sender reputation you’ve spent the entirety of the year building. An unexpected email spike in late November is the kind of thing that can land crucial December communications in the spam folder.

Tailor your messages to different audiences

Split your list and write to each of your audiences intentionally rather than trying to create one message that appeals to everyone.

A university, for example, might separate prospective students, current students, alumni, and donors, since December means something different to each. A nonprofit might treat Giving Tuesday and the year-end appeal as two campaigns for two audiences instead of one long push, and a concert venue might send only to people who attended a similar event last season.

Let subscribers choose their holiday emails

Instead of sending every holiday campaign to everyone, let people tell you what they want through their opt-in and subscription history. To encourage opt-ins, try adding a banner in your regular sends through late October and November, asking whether they’re interested in holiday offers, early access to new features, or year-end updates.

For people who’d rather opt out, a standard unsubscribe option is all or nothing: one button in your footer removes them from everything you send. Specific subscriptions give them a middle option. Create one for each kind of email you send, like holiday offers, event invitations, fundraising appeals, or a monthly newsletter. No matter what list they’re on, contacts still hear from you at your usual cadence, and the content is tailored more closely to what they want to read.

December and beyond

The right holiday frequency is whatever your audience and your sender reputation can both carry. Start slow, give people a way to tell you what they want to hear from you this season, and let what you see decide your next move.

See how Emma can support your email program this season →

 

Contact Us

Want to engage your
audience and grow your brand? 

See how Emma helps you create, optimize, and send email campaigns with confidence.