Category Archive: Tracking and response detail

Our Facebook poll sparks a discussion

Last week, we posted a quick poll on Facebook about our email sending strategies, and we were happy to see so many fans weigh in. What’s equally wonderful is their willingness to share their strategies with others and keep the dialogue humming.

We asked, “Do you send one newsletter per month? Or do you send more or less frequently? Tell us and share your reasons.” View the results on our Facebook wall, and take a look at a few of the responses here:

  • “We take the best of our blog and share it with our list every quarter.” – Tim Frick, MightyBytes
  • “We publish 3 monthly, 1 bi-monthly and 2 quarterly e-newsletters, each to specific audiences and with specific goals. We also publish 2-5 ad hoc email communiques each month depending on the time of year.” – Mike Barzacchini, Mike Barzacchini Communication
  • “Once a month, except December – 4x. I’m in retail. Concerned that more than once a month would be a turn off to clientele.” – Susan Iris Landa, The Fossil Cartel and Let It Bead
  • “We try to keep our Facebook, LinkedIn and Twitter pages very active during the week so our students and fans can know what is going on while also getting a meatier communication via your newsletter system monthly. We’ve found the diverse marketplace of our demographic (18-60+) have so many preferred ways to reach them (Facebook, email, phone, newsletter, Twitter…) that the only way to truly embrace their needs is to be as diverse as they are in our communication strategies.” – Momenta Workshops

All of these great responses got us thinking about sending frequency and segmentation, namely…

1. How do you know when you’ve reached the point of saturation?
Some folks rely on gut feeling or personal experience, knowing that they don’t appreciate an over-cluttered inbox. Make sure to employ the response metrics at your disposal as well. For example, do your opt-out rates increase when you send more or less frequently? Do open rates increase or decrease? If you’ve noticed a shift in either direction, it’s worth some attention. And check out Megan’s post with more tips for avoiding the affliction known as email overload.

2. Are you segmenting your Emma audience appropriately?
Remember that your audience is made up of a variety of members with different tendencies and needs. Your biggest fans may want to hear from you more than once a month, while others prefer less frequent communication. Use Emma’s search and segment feature to create audience groups based on location if you’d like to send more regularly to subscribers in your home city, based on or purchase history, if you’d like to concentrate on recurring buyers. The best way to gauge audience preferences? Ask them.

3. What’s your content strategy?
While it’s important to consider sending frequency, don’t forget that your best ammunition is your content. If you’re crafting stories that people love, they’ll find time to read (and share with their friends) at any time of the week or month. Your sending schedule can be as flexible or rigid as you like, as long as you’re taking the time to develop compelling content.

4. Have you diversified your communication channels?
As our friends at Momenta Workshops recognize, your communication strategy should extend past email. An integrated approach — using email, social media and, yes, even phone calls — means you’ll reach each sector of your audience at the time(s) they’re likeliest to be receptive.

Thanks to everyone who participated in our Facebook poll! If you’d like to contribute more to the conversation, please leave a comment here.


Meet the University of Chicago

University of Chicago newsletterHow a world-class university stays on top of the curve with email campaigns.

About their newsletter.

As senior web editor at the University of Chicago, Laurie Davis sends weekly newsletters to a mix of faculty, staff, students, the Board of Trustees and other subscribers. Sounds like a pretty broad audience and lots of information to deliver, right? With smart formatting and careful analysis, Davis and her team handle the challenge with style.

“The newsletter helps us highlight innovative research at the university,” says Davis, “showcase students and faculty who are doing fascinating things in the world, draw attention to prominent media stories that mention scholars, announce new appointments and highlight upcoming campus events.”

With an audience of around 30,000 subscribers, keeping track of recipient behavior — and a mailing’s success — wouldn’t be possible without the ability to review who’s received, opened, clicked or shared the newsletter. Davis continues, “We like the ability to review such a robust amount of data that Emma provides in the response section of the interface. The response metrics allow us to evaluate our content by seeing which stories our readers are choosing to click on.”

Take their July 29th newsletter, for example. Of all clicks, more than one-third were on their top news story, “Sunil Kumar named dean of Chicago Booth School of Business.” That’s a pretty startling bit of data, and it shows how effective placement of a timely story can give you just the kind of response you were hoping for from your audience. (That’s lots of clicks, of course.)

Why we like it.

It includes a 3-5 main stories that are summarized and followed by “full story” links, so curious readers can click to read more. This allows for overall brevity in the campaign itself and enables Davis’ team to track reader interest, shaping upcoming stories and their placement in future newsletters.

In short: Heed your readers’ busy lives and crowded inboxes. A typical reader probably won’t weed through paragraphs and paragraphs of text to find the content that grabs them. Make that content easy to find and quick to digest. Your readers with a short attention span will absorb the summaries, while readers with more time to peruse will click to read the complete story.

Visually, UChicago News’ format is consistent. A custom layout provides sections for Top Stories, Events, News Coverage and Announcements. Newsletter sections are in maroon text, with story titles in blue and story text in gray.

In short: Make consistent, intentional style choices. Choose font types and colors with an eye for readability (bonus points for you if these choices match the look of your website or brand). A well-formatted campaign draws attention away from the formatting and spotlights your content. And isn’t that the point, after all?

The send-off, at a glance.

  • Sent on July 29, 2010 to 29,319 people
  • Open rate: 33%
  • 26 shares, 33 trackable visits
  • Subject line: Kumar Named Chicago Booth Dean / UChicago News / July 29, 2010
  • Created using a custom layout

More details

See the campaign online
See the website


Meet the-e-list

the-e-list campaign image How a stylish, in-the-know gal stays connected to her subscribers and the Connecticut shoreline.

About the newsletter.

Every week, Erica Tannen provides her subscribers with news about art, restaurants, services, shopping and more near the Connecticut shoreline. the-e-list is “an excruciatingly opinionated guide” that brings attention to new businesses and trends near the shoreline, and it rounds out Erica’s other unique offerings, including the e-card and PeRKS programs.

Since she conceived the idea for her newsletter in 2009 (“my crazy idea is to develop an online community of like-minded souls on the shoreline”), Erica’s list has grown from just over 1,500 folks to nearly 5,000. Using Emma’s Social Sharing feature, she sees even more growth on the horizon — in this campaign alone, 12 audience members shared via Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn or email, leading to 83 visits from non-subscribers. Looks like her crazy idea is paying off.

Why we like it.

It’s packed with fresh and timely content. A July sale at a jewelry boutique. A gourmet cookie shop with extreme flavors like Kahlua and key lime. College students that started a mini-catering business. A farm-to-table oyster bar. Survey Tannen’s summer newsletters, and you’ll find these businesses and more enthusiastically profiled.
In short: Know your audience’s interests and create your campaigns with them in mind. Love the things they love, and they’ll be sure to love you back.

It utilizes ad space in a smart way. Erica worked with the Emma designers to create a custom layout with plenty of ad space along the newsletter’s right side. Now, Erica can feature rotating advertisements, and her sponsors reach thousands of inboxes weekly.
In short: Consider offering ad sponsorships in your newsletter. Pick a layout that will highlight ads in a prominent way, and you may just cover the costs of your mailing. Check out our suggestion for selling ads here.

The send-off, at a glance.

  • Sent on July 14, 2010, to 4,856 people
  • Open rate: 43% :: Click-through rate: 38%
  • 12 shares via Social Sharing, 83 trackable visits
  • Subject line: All good things in Essex, 7/14/2010
  • Created using a custom layout

More details

See the campaign online
See the website


Interactive Charts: Let the data-loving begin

Now in your response section, you’ll find Interactive Charts, displaying all of the useful email results that Emma collects for you in a handy, visual way. You’ll know at a glance how your campaigns perform over time. You’ll see individual results unfold over hourly increments. And best of all, these new charts make it easy to spot trends and patterns in your email strategy. (And they look so nice. Is it wrong to have a crush on a chart?)

Which trends might you identify, you ask? Well, seeing your data packaged so handsomely might lead you to several conclusions. Consider these scenarios:

1) Your clicks and opens drop in months with a higher sending volume.
Maybe you’re sending too frequently.


Not to induce high school math flashbacks, but this pattern is an example of the ol’ inverse relationship. As the number of campaigns goes up, your audience engagement goes down.

What to do? Consider sending fewer emails. You can consolidate messages or modify content so that your various audience groups only get the most relevant and tailored messages. (Not to be confused with messages from your tailor. That reminds us, we have to pick up our dry cleaning.)

2) You don’t see consistency with either results or volume.
Sounds as if your results are just, well, all over the place.


When the campaigns line jumps around, you may notice that your results are a bit erratic as well.

What to do? Build some consistency with your sending schedule so your audience knows what to expect. Set a realistic goal for how often you’ll send. If sending once a week is too much, aim for every other week or once a month. Then see what your most popular campaigns have in common — a morning send-off time, or a certain kind of content — to make those things a more consistent part of your strategy.

3) Your opens drop but your clicks go up.
Perhaps you have fewer, more engaged readers.




If your open rate remains relatively low but your click rates are high or even increasing, your content might be hitting the spot with only some of your audience.

What to do? You might test different subject lines or do something to encourage those folks who are signed up but appear to have checked out (then impress your colleagues by calling it a “re-engagement campaign”). Or look at your signup form – maybe you’re attracting people who don’t really connect with your organization. Send a survey to find out how often your subscribers would like to hear from you and what topics interest them.

4) Your opens and clicks are both falling.
Your measures of engagement may be decreasing over time.


Sometimes your strategy and content might need a little shake-up, and seeing a graph like this is one suggests that your audience is ready for a change.

What to do? Take a fresh look at your content and sending strategy. Think about new ways your emails can bring value to your subscribers, whether it’s new content, different promotions or something else entirely. Consider a new designed look, or try laying out your content in a different way. Some Emma customers have sent an Emma survey to learn what their subscribers like best and what they’d prefer to see less of, then used the feedback to relaunch their newsletter strategy. It’s a fantastic way to build better relationships with your members *and* have better email results to show for it.

And, as always, remember that you should only take a data-driven romance so far. Numbers are only impressive if they’re relevant to your own goals.

If you’re an Emma customer, go ahead and login to your account … you’ll start seeing your response data in a whole new way.